ยท Paul Connolly
From 6 April 2027, private medical insurance moves onto the payslip. The tax on it gets collected through payroll every month, instead of being settled on a P11D after the year ends.
Most of the commentary treats this as an admin job. The part I'd plan for is the first year. In 2027/28, finance pays Class 1A National Insurance twice in the same twelve months, and some of your people will see old tax and new tax being collected at once. Neither is a problem if you see it coming. Both cause awkward conversations if you don't.
This guide covers the change in brief, where 2027/28 bites, the parts that are specific to private medical insurance, and who needs to own what before the end of March.
The change in brief
From 6 April 2027, HMRC requires employers to payroll these benefits (HMRC interim guidance):
- company cars and car fuel
- vans and van fuel
- employer-provided medical benefits
Income Tax on them, plus employer Class 1A National Insurance, is reported and paid through each pay run. Most other taxable benefits follow from 6 April 2028, while employment-related loans and living accommodation stay voluntary for now. The government reconfirmed this timetable at the Autumn Budget on 28 October 2026 (PwC).
Three details that are easy to miss (TaxCalc):
- 2026/27 P11Ds are still due by 6 July 2027.
- You may still need P11Ds in 2027/28 for benefits outside the April 2027 group.
- There's nothing to register for. Payrolling the April 2027 benefits simply becomes the default.
Why 2027/28 is the year to plan for
Finance: two lots of Class 1A in one year
In July 2027 you'll pay Class 1A for 2026/27 the old way. From April 2027 you'll also be paying Class 1A on the April 2027 benefits month by month (TaxCalc). The total liability doesn't change, but the payments overlap. If your finance director hasn't budgeted for that, the summer cash flow will be a surprise.
Employees: the "double tax" feeling
HMRC will take these benefits out of tax codes before April 2027, so nobody is taxed twice on the same benefit. Underpayments from earlier years stay in the tax code, though (TaxCalc). So some people will see old tax collected through their code alongside new monthly tax on their payslip. The maths is right, and it will still feel like a double hit (Buzzacott).
Anyone finding that hard can contact HMRC and ask about spreading what they owe (ICAEW). Worth putting that in your employee comms.
Payroll: a softer first year, with limits
HMRC won't charge inaccuracy penalties on these payroll returns in 2027/28 unless errors are deliberate. Late filing and late payment penalties still apply, and the full penalty regime starts in 2028/29 (HMRC: penalties and interest). Use the first year to get the process working while mistakes cost less.
Where private medical insurance gets awkward
Private medical insurance is definitely in. Whether "employer-provided medical benefits" also covers dental insurance, health cash plans or other insurance-based health benefits is less settled: Buzzacott flagged it as unclear, while James Cowper Kreston listed dental as included. If you provide any of these, get a written answer from your payroll provider or accountant.
The bigger issue is timing. Insurance renews on its own calendar, and payroll now needs every change before that month's cut-off. Buzzacott highlights four situations worth planning for:
| Situation | What happens | What to agree now |
|---|---|---|
| Renewal partway through the tax year | A new premium changes the taxable value mid-year | Who sends payroll the new figures, and by when |
| Joiner on full medical underwriting | Confirmation can take a few weeks, so several months of benefit may land on one payslip | Whether to warn the employee, and how backdated values are handled |
| Leaver | Their final benefit value has to be ready for the last pay run | Who tells payroll the leaving date and final value |
| Employee on statutory pay | In some months, their pay may be lower than their benefit charge | How payroll handles it, and who explains it to the employee |
Ask your insurer or adviser how quickly they confirm joiners, leavers and changes. Then put that next to your payroll cut-off date. Any gap between the two is where errors will come from.
Who owns what before April
Most errors happen when a change falls between HR, payroll and finance. Give each of these a named owner and a date, and you've done most of the work.
| Area | Owner | What done looks like | Suggested date |
|---|---|---|---|
| Benefits list | HR | Every taxable benefit, who receives it, and whether it's in the April 2027 or April 2028 group. Your last P11D is a good starting point | End of January |
| Grey-area benefits | Payroll provider or accountant | A written answer on whether dental, health cash plans or other health benefits are in the April 2027 group | End of January |
| Payroll readiness | Payroll provider or bureau | Software confirmed ready, the data they need, the monthly cut-off, and who checks the taxable values | End of January |
| Class 1A budget | Finance | 2026/27 Class 1A in July 2027 and monthly Class 1A from April 2027 both in the 2027/28 budget | Before the budget is signed off |
| Joiners, leavers and changes | HR, with your insurer or adviser | Insurer turnaround times matched to the payroll cut-off, and one named person sending changes to payroll | End of February |
| Employee communication | HR | A one-page explainer in February, then an annotated example payslip with the April pay run, covering the "double tax" feeling and who to ask | February and April |
The dates above are suggested planning dates, not HMRC deadlines.
Bring your benefits list to a Reality Check
Getting ready for April means listing every benefit and who gets it. Once you've got that list, bring it to my free Benefits Reality Check. I'll look at what each benefit costs, who's actually using it, and where the gaps are. No jargon, no hard sell.
Book your Benefits Reality CheckThis article is general information based on HMRC guidance and adviser commentary published up to 6 November 2026. It isn't tax, legal or financial advice. HMRC is still finalising some of the detail, so check the latest position with your payroll provider or accountant before acting.
Paul Connolly trading as Connolly Collective is an appointed representative of New Leaf Distribution Ltd, which is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. Firm registration number 460421.
Sources
- HMRC: the phased introduction of mandatory payrolling: phase 1 and phase 2 dates and benefits, loans and accommodation staying voluntary
- HMRC: the default operation of mandatory payrolling: the April 2027 list, including Class 1A in real time
- HMRC: penalties and interest: 2027/28 soft landing, penalties from 2028/29
- PwC: Autumn Budget 2026: timetable reconfirmed at the 28 October 2026 Budget
- TaxCalc (27 Aug 2026): P11D still needed, no registration for mandatory benefits, tax code removal and earlier underpayments, Class 1A overlap
- Buzzacott (21 Aug 2026): uncertainty over which medical benefits are in scope, renewal dates, underwriting delays, leavers, statutory pay, the "double tax" feeling
- James Cowper Kreston (22 Jun 2026): lists dental as included in phase 1
- ICAEW (6 May 2025): employees can ask HMRC to spread an underpayment
