Small business colleagues reviewing business continuity plans in an IT office

    Key person cover

    Key person insurance for UK SMEs: cover and tax explained

    All Free Insights

    · Paul Connolly

    What would you do if your best revenue-generating employee died tomorrow?

    Sophie runs a 22-person IT support company in the East Midlands. Her co-founder, Dan, runs sales and brought in the four biggest clients. On a Sunday in March he collapses on a charity bike ride and dies before he reaches hospital. He was 46.

    By Monday afternoon the phone calls start. A client rings Dan's mobile to chase a quote for a network upgrade, and nobody knows what price Dan had in mind. Two new contracts worth around £180,000 a year between them were due to sign that month, and both prospects had only ever dealt with Dan.

    Six weeks later one of those prospects has signed with a competitor. The largest existing client has put its contract out to tender. The bank that lent the business £150,000 last year, backed by personal guarantees from both founders, wants up-to-date management accounts. Dan's shares have passed to his wife under his will, and she wants to know what they are worth.

    Sophie and Dan are invented, but each of these problems is a common result of losing a key person without warning. Most of them come down to money.

    What losing a key person does to profits

    The first loss is sales. Clients and prospects buy from people they know, and that relationship does not pass to whoever picks up the file. Deals stall and renewals that would have gone through on a phone call get put out to tender.

    The second loss is everything the person carried in their head, such as how a big account was priced or the history behind a long-running supplier dispute. Replacing them means recruitment fees and often months before the new hire performs at the same level, while the rest of the team covers the gap and their own work slips.

    The money problems that follow

    Lower income does not lower the bills. Salaries, rent, VAT and loan repayments still leave the account every month, so a business that was comfortable in January can be short of cash by April.

    Borrowing makes it harder. Business loans often come with conditions, usually called covenants, that require profit or turnover to stay above a set level. A sharp fall can put you in breach, which may let the lender review the loan. It is worth checking your loan agreement for any clause about the death or departure of a named director. Where directors have signed personal guarantees, their own homes and savings are exposed if the business cannot pay.

    The value of the business drops as well, because a buyer will pay less for revenue that depended on someone who is no longer there.

    If the person who died owned shares, those shares go to their estate and usually to their family. The surviving owners can end up sharing the company with someone who has no part in running it, while the family may want cash for shares they cannot easily sell. Key person cover is the wrong tool for that. Shareholder protection exists to give the remaining owners the money to buy the shares, and the two policies are often arranged together.

    Who counts as a key person in your business

    A key person is anyone whose death or serious illness would cause a real loss of profit. In most SMEs that list is longer than the managing director, and it often includes some of these people.

    • The founder or managing director, especially if clients or lenders deal with them personally.
    • A top salesperson who wins a large share of new business or manages the biggest accounts.
    • A technical specialist, such as a lead developer or a qualified engineer whose sign-off the business needs to trade.
    • A director who holds the relationship with the bank or a major supplier.
    • An operations or finance lead who runs processes nobody else fully understands.

    To test it, imagine the person stops work tomorrow and estimate what happens to profit over the next 12 to 24 months. If that number would worry you, they are a key person.

    How key person insurance works

    Key person insurance is a policy the business takes out on the life of someone it depends on. The business owns the policy and any payout goes to the business, not to the person's family. The key person has to agree to the cover and answer the insurer's health questions.

    It is normally set up as term insurance, which pays a lump sum if the person dies within a fixed number of years and nothing after that. Many insurers also offer critical illness cover alongside it, so the business can claim if the person is diagnosed with a serious illness that meets the policy definition.

    The amount of cover should match the profit you would lose plus the cost of getting back on your feet, and the insurer will ask how you arrived at the figure. The length of the policy usually matches how long the person is expected to stay in the role.

    When a claim is paid, the money can replace lost profit while the business rebuilds, pay for an interim hire, reduce borrowing or give the remaining directors time to make decisions without a cash crisis behind each one. For Sophie, it could have paid for an experienced interim sales director and kept the bank onside while she rebuilt the pipeline.

    How key person cover is taxed

    HMRC decides the tax treatment by looking at why the business took out the policy. Its guidance sits in the Business Income Manual at BIM45525 and BIM45530.

    When the premiums reduce your corporation tax bill

    HMRC allows the premiums as a business expense when both of these are true.

    1. The only reason for the policy is to protect the business's trading profits if it loses the key person. Cover taken out to protect the value of the company or its shares does not count.
    2. A life policy is pure term cover with no savings or investment element, and it runs no longer than the person is likely to be useful to the business.

    This is HMRC's "wholly and exclusively" test, which in plain terms means the cost has to be purely for the business. Whole of life policies, and any policy with an investment element, fail it. If a lender insists on the cover as a condition of a loan, the premiums cannot be claimed as a cost of arranging that loan either.

    If the premiums are allowed, the payout is taxed

    Where the premiums have been allowed, HMRC treats any payout as taxable business income. Where they have not, the general rule is that the payout is not taxed, although HMRC says this is not guaranteed.

    This changes how much cover you need. Say Sophie works out that losing Dan would cost the business £300,000 in lost profit and replacement costs over two years. If the premiums were allowed and the payout were taxed at the current 25% main rate of corporation tax, she would need about £400,000 of cover to keep £300,000. If the premiums were not allowed and the payout were not taxed, £300,000 of cover would do the job. These figures are illustrative.

    Owner-directors are the tricky case

    BIM45530 says there may be a personal purpose behind a policy where it covers directors who are major shareholders but no other employees. HMRC's example is a director whose death would hit the value of the company's shares, where protecting that value and the director's estate may be part of the reason for the cover. A policy with a mixed purpose fails the test.

    Dan owned half the company, so a policy on him would stand a real chance of being refused tax relief. The cover would still do its job, but Sophie should size it on the basis that the payout is unlikely to be taxed. Cover on a key employee with no shares, such as a top salesperson, is the more straightforward case.

    Some websites quote a 5% shareholding limit. HMRC's guidance does not mention one. It looks at the evidence of what the directors were trying to achieve, so agree the treatment with your accountant before the policy starts and record the reason for the cover in a board minute.

    What to do next

    1. List the people whose loss would hurt profit most, including employees who own no shares.
    2. Put a rough figure on that loss over two years, including recruitment and interim costs.
    3. Check your loan agreements and personal guarantees for anything tied to a named director.
    4. Ask your accountant how the premiums and any payout would be taxed in your company, and size the cover on that basis.
    5. If any of those people own shares, look at shareholder protection at the same time.

    If you would like help with any of these, book an online intro call with Connolly Collective. We will work through it with you and your accountant.

    Book an online intro call

    This article is general information based on HMRC guidance as at November 2026. It is not tax advice or a personal recommendation, and tax treatment depends on individual circumstances and can change.

    Paul Connolly trading as Connolly Collective is an appointed representative of New Leaf Distribution Ltd, which is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. Firm registration number 460421.

    Sources

    • HMRC, BIM45525 Specific deductions, insurance, employees and other key persons
    • HMRC, BIM45530 Specific deductions, insurance, key persons, non-trade purposes
    • HMRC, Corporation Tax rates and allowances