Shareholder protection

    Cross-option agreements explained in plain English

    By Paul Connolly · Last reviewed 15 November 2026 · 5 min read

    This guide explains what a cross-option agreement is, how it works and why it matters for inheritance tax.

    If you've looked into shareholder protection, you'll have come across the term cross-option agreement. It sounds technical, but the idea is simple. It's the legal agreement that sits alongside the insurance and makes sure shares can be bought and sold smoothly if a shareholder dies or becomes seriously ill.

    What is a cross-option agreement?

    A cross-option agreement is a contract between the shareholders of a company. It gives each side an option, which is a right they can choose to use:

    • the surviving shareholders get an option to buy the shares of a shareholder who has died
    • the deceased shareholder's estate gets an option to sell those shares to the surviving shareholders

    Neither side has to do anything until one of them uses its option. Once one side does, the other is bound to go through with the sale.

    You may also see it called a double option agreement or, informally, a business will.

    Why you need an agreement as well as insurance

    Shareholder protection insurance provides the money to buy the shares. On its own, it doesn't make anyone sell. Without an agreement, the family of a shareholder who has died could decide to keep the shares, or to sell them to someone else, even though the money is sitting there.

    The cross-option agreement closes that gap. It means the survivors can insist on buying, and the family can insist on selling, at a price worked out in the way you've all agreed.

    How it works, step by step

    1. The shareholders agree how the shares will be valued.
    2. Each shareholder takes out a life policy on their own life for the value of their shares, usually written into a business trust for the other shareholders.
    3. A solicitor drafts the cross-option agreement and all the shareholders sign it.
    4. If a shareholder dies, the insurer pays the policy money to the trustees for the surviving shareholders.
    5. Either the survivors or the estate uses its option.
    6. The survivors buy the shares with the policy money, and the estate receives the cash.

    Why not a simple buy and sell agreement?

    A buy and sell agreement obliges the survivors to buy and the estate to sell as soon as a shareholder dies. That can count as a binding contract for sale. If the shares are subject to a binding contract for sale at the date of death, they can lose business relief from inheritance tax.

    With a cross-option agreement, nobody is obliged to buy or sell at the moment of death. The sale only becomes binding once an option is used. HMRC has accepted that an option that hasn't been used at the date of death isn't a binding contract for sale, which is why cross-option agreements are designed to keep business relief available.

    Business relief after April 2026

    From 6 April 2026, 100% business relief is limited to the first £2.5 million of combined business and agricultural property per person, with 50% relief above that. Any unused allowance can pass to a surviving spouse or civil partner. Government figures show that 96% of estates claiming business property relief claimed for business property below £2.5 million, so for many owners the relief still matters a great deal. It's worth making sure your agreement doesn't put it at risk.

    What about serious illness?

    A shareholder protection arrangement can include critical illness cover. Agreements often deal with serious illness differently from death, for example by giving the ill shareholder an option to sell without letting the others force a sale. Your solicitor will explain how yours works.

    What the agreement should cover

    • How the shares will be valued, and how often the valuation is reviewed
    • How long each side has to use its option
    • What happens on death, terminal illness and critical illness
    • What happens if a shareholder leaves or the policies end
    • How the agreement fits with your articles of association and any shareholder agreement

    Who drafts it?

    A solicitor should draft or check the agreement. Insurers publish specimen agreements, and they say these are for you and your legal advisers to consider. I work alongside your solicitor and accountant so the insurance and the agreement match.

    Questions directors ask

    This guide is general information only and isn't a personal recommendation or legal advice. Tax treatment depends on your circumstances and may change.

    Sources

    The facts in these articles were checked against the pages below on 14 November 2026. Recheck them before each annual review.

    • Royal London: shareholder protection: options and business property relief (Articles 2, 4)
    • Legal & General Share Protection technical guide: buy and sell agreements, cross-option agreements and business relief (Articles 2, 4)
    • GOV.UK: agricultural property relief and business property relief changes: £2.5 million allowance, transferability and the 96% figure (Articles 2, 4)
    • HMRC IHTM25520: 100% relief allowance: allowance for deaths on or after 6 April 2026 (Article 4)
    Paul Connolly

    Paul Connolly

    I'm Paul Connolly, founder of Connolly Collective. I've spent ten years in UK employee benefits and protection, on both the insurer and the adviser side, and I'm CII qualified.

    Next step

    If you have shareholder protection without an agreement, or an agreement that hasn't been looked at in years, book a 20-minute online intro call. Book an online intro call or read more about shareholder protection.

    Related articles

    Shareholder protection

    What happens to your shares if a co-director dies?

    This guide explains what happens to shares when a director dies, the problems it can cause on both sides, and how shareholder protection is designed to solve them.

    5 min read15 November 2026

    Approved

    Let's talk it through

    Pick a time for a 20-minute online intro call. No obligation, no hard sell.

    Loading booking times…

    Prefer to send a message? Email paul@connollycollective.co.uk

    Paul Connolly, trading as Connolly Collective, is an Appointed Representative of New Leaf Distribution Ltd, which is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. New Leaf Distribution Ltd's Financial Services Register number is 460421. You can check this on the Financial Services Register.

    The information on this page is for general guidance only and isn't a personal recommendation. Tax treatment depends on your circumstances and may change.